USCG Exam PracticeRule 2 — Responsibility
A vessel's master strictly follows all applicable Inland Navigation Rules but fails to take a precaution that the ordinary practice of seamen would require under the circumstances. A collision results. Which statement correctly describes the legal effect of Rule 2(a)?
- A. The master is exonerated because the Rules were followed to the letter.
- B. Only the vessel owner bears liability because the master acted in good faith.
- ✓ The vessel, owner, master, and crew remain exposed to liability for neglect of that precaution.Correct
- D. Liability is limited to the crew members who were on watch at the time.
Why C is correct
33 CFR §83.02(a) expressly states that nothing in the Rules exonerates any vessel, owner, master, or crew from the consequences of neglecting any precaution required by the ordinary practice of seamen. Literal compliance with specific Rules does not eliminate liability for seamanship failures.
Cited:33 CFR §83.02